Understanding the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system in India is essential for every business and professional. One area that often causes confusion is the difference between Orders, Notifications, and Circulars. These are all formal instruments used by the government to manage and implement GST law. However, their purpose, authority, and legal impact are different. This blog explains each one clearly and helps you understand when and how they apply in real-life business situations.
What Are GST Notifications?
Definition
GST Notifications are legal instruments issued by the central or state government under the GST Act. All stakeholders are bound by them after publication in the Official Gazette. Notifications implement laws or revise tax rates, exemptions, or procedural timelines.
Key Features
- Issued by the Central Government or State Governments based on recommendations of the GST Council.
- Always published in the Official Gazette.
- They modify, clarify, or bring provisions of the GST law into force.
- Binding on all taxpayers and officers.
Common Types of Notifications
- GST rate changes for goods and services.
- Exemptions for specific categories.
- Extension of due dates for return filings.
- New procedural requirements or amendments to old ones.
Example
Let’s say the GST Council recommends reducing the GST rate on electric vehicles from 12% to 5%. This change is implemented through a Notification by the Ministry of Finance and published in the Official Gazette.
What Are GST Circulars?
Definition
GST Circulars are explanatory documents issued by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC). They are not new laws but are used to explain how existing provisions of GST law should be interpreted or implemented.
Key Features
- Issued only by the CBIC.
- They are binding on GST officers, but not necessarily on taxpayers or courts.
- Meant to provide clarity and consistency in applying GST law.
Purpose
- Clarify ambiguous provisions of the law.
- Give direction to officers on how to apply the law uniformly.
- Provide guidance on refunds, input tax credit (ITC), reverse charge, etc.
Example
A Circular might explain whether GST is applicable on post-sale discounts offered by suppliers. It does not change the law but helps officers interpret it the same way across the country.
What Are GST Orders?
Definition
GST Orders are executive instructions or administrative directives issued by the CBIC or GST authorities. They are often used to assign powers, designate officers, or address issues not covered directly by Notifications or Circulars.
Key Features
- Used for administrative and operational purposes.
- May not always be published in the Official Gazette.
- Internal departmental clarity and efficiency.
Examples of GST Orders
- Assigning jurisdiction of a taxpayer to a particular GST officer.
- Delegating authority to a department for conducting audits.
- Specifying timelines for certain assessments or appeals.
Key Differences Between Notifications, Circulars, and Orders
| Feature | Notifications | Circulars | Orders |
|---|---|---|---|
| Issuing Authority | Government (Central/State) | CBIC | CBIC/GST Officers |
| Legal Binding | Yes, on all taxpayers and officers | Only on department officers | Binding within department |
| Purpose | Implement or change law | Clarify law interpretation | Administrative execution |
| Publication Requirement | Yes, in Official Gazette | CBIC Portal | Not always required |
| Scope | Broad – affects all taxpayers | Specific – targets unclear provisions | Internal – procedural or structural |
Why Understanding the Difference Is Important
Knowing how to interpret these instruments is essential for:
-
Tax compliance: To avoid penalties due to misunderstanding of the law.
-
Correct filing: Return timelines and forms often change via Notifications.
-
Efficient dispute handling: Referring to Circulars helps explain your position.
- Administrative clarity: Orders help businesses understand who their jurisdictional officer is, especially in large corporations.
Legal Hierarchy: Act vs Notification vs Circular vs Order
-
GST Act: Highest legal authority.
-
Notifications: Implement changes allowed under the Act.
-
Circulars: Clarify law for officers (not binding on courts).
- Orders: Assist with GST framework administration.
If there is a conflict:
- The Act overrides Notifications.
- Notifications override Circulars and Orders.
- Circulars cannot supersede laws or Notifications.
Real-life Use Cases
For more insights and simplified explanations, you can also explore resources available at theGSTco, a reliable platform for practical GST updates and compliance support.
Case 1: Using Notification to Extend Return Filing Date
A due date extension for GSTR-3B is not in the Act. The Ministry issues a Notification extending the date. This is mandatory for taxpayers.
Case 2: Clarification on ITC for Promotional Samples
A Circular is issued stating that ITC is not allowed for goods distributed free of cost as part of marketing. Though not law, GST officers use this as the basis for assessments.
Case 3: Jurisdiction Change Through Order
The CBIC issues an Order transferring control of taxpayers with turnover above ₹5 crores from State GST to Central GST officers. This impacts audits, notices, and appeals.
How to Access Notifications, Circulars, and Orders
| Notification No | Date of Issue | Subject | Notification Highlight |
|---|---|---|---|
| 53/2023-Central Tax | 02-11-2023 | Special procedure for condonation of appeal delay | Allows submission of appeals via FORM GST APL-01 until January 31, 2024 |
| 52/2023-Central Tax | 26-10-2023 | Amendments to CGST Rules, 2017 | Implements recommendations from the 52nd GST Council Meeting |
| 51/2023-Central Tax | 29-09-2023 | Amendments to CGST Rules, effective from October 1, 2023 | Changes in registration, online gaming valuation, and related tax aspects |
| 50/2023-Central Tax | 29-09-2023 | Excluding some actionable claims | Advance tax on actionable claims |
| 49/2023-Central Tax | 29-09-2023 | Notification under section 15(5) of CGST Act | Includes supply of online gaming, other than online money gaming, and actionable casino claims |
| 48/2023-Central Tax | 29-09-2023 | Notification of GST (Amendment) Act, 2023 provisions effective October 1, 2023. | |
| 47/2023-Central Tax | 25-09-2023 | Amendment to procedures for Pan Masala and Tobacco | Effective from January 1, 2024 |
| 46/2023-Central Tax | 18-09-2023 | Appointment of adjudicating authority | Appointed for M/s Inukat Infrasol Pvt. Ltd. |
| 45/2023-Central Tax | 06-09-2023 | New Rules 31B and 31C for gaming valuation | Guidelines for online gaming, casino, and actionable claims valuation |
| 44/2023-Central Tax | 25-08-2023 | Extension of GSTR-7 due date for Manipur customers (April-July 2023) to August 25, 2023. | |
| 43/2023-Central Tax | 25-08-2023 | Extension of GSTR-3B due date For Manipur users (June quarter) until August 25, 2023 | |
| 42/2023-Central Tax | 25-08-2023 | Extension of GSTR-3B due date for Manipur customers (April-July 2023) to August 25, 2023. |
All official documents are available on:
-
CBIC Portal
-
GST Council Website
- Finance Ministry Gazette
Make sure to verify:
- Notification number
- Date of effect
- Superseding clause (if it replaces an older one)
Tips to Stay Updated
- Visit trusted sources like thegstco.com for curated GST updates and practical insights.
- Subscribe to GST newsletters from CA firms.
- Use apps like CBIC-GST mobile app.
- Regularly visit the “What’s New” section on the CBIC portal.
- Attend GST webinars from recognized sources.
Misinterpretations to Avoid
- Treating a Circular as if it changes the law.
- Ignoring Orders assuming they are not relevant.
- Confusing the purpose of Circulars with Notifications.
- Using outdated Notifications without checking for replacements.
FAQs
Q1. Are GST Notifications applicable to everyone?
Yes. Notifications are legally binding and apply to all registered taxpayers and GST officers.
Q2. Can a taxpayer ignore a GST Circular?
Since Circulars do not obligate taxpayers, yes. But it is recommended to follow them for smooth compliance.
Q3. How do GST Orders differ from Notifications?
Orders deal with administrative functions, while Notifications bring legal changes under GST law.
Q4. Are Circulars issued under the GST Act?
CBIC can issue Circulars under CGST Act Section 168.
Q5. Can courts strike down a Circular?
Yes. If a Circular is found contrary to the law, courts can declare it invalid.
Q6. What is the frequency of GST Notifications?
Notifications are issued frequently—sometimes multiple times in a month, depending on the GST Council meetings and policy decisions.
Q7. How to check if a Notification is still valid?
Always check for the latest updates or if a newer Notification has replaced the old one.
