Skip to content

Advantages and Disadvantages of Right Issue of Shares: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction

In the dynamic landscape of corporate finance, companies often seek innovative avenues to bolster their financial resources and fuel growth. One such mechanism is a rights issue, a strategic tool employed by businesses to raise capital while maintaining shareholder control and preserving ownership integrity.

A rights issue, at its core, grants existing shareholders the exclusive privilege to purchase additional shares at a predetermined price, typically below the prevailing market rate. This mechanism not only injects fresh capital into the company but also fosters a sense of inclusivity among its stakeholders.

In this comprehensive guide, we delve into the intricacies of rights issues, exploring their definition, purpose, advantages, disadvantages, and alternative avenues. By the end of this article, readers will gain a nuanced understanding of rights issues, equipped with the knowledge to navigate the complexities of corporate fundraising and capital expansion.

Definition of Rights Issue

A rights issue is a fundraising tool which allows a company to attract additional funds from the individual shareholders that have been acquired since it first began operating. It does this by providing existing shareholders with a predated right to acquire new shares of the company which are sold out at a price lower than the stock's current value on the market when such shares are made available. These writings are directed to shareholders according to them having the shares that are proportional. The number of rights are allotted to them in corresponding to the number of shares that they hold.

Rights issue aims to solve the purpose

Companies utilize rights issues for various reasons, with the most common being:

  • Raising Capital: The foremost goal is to produce more cash for the enterprise with the help of it.
  • Funding Expansion: Businesses often spend capital on developing new products, innovation, or business development to increase sales.
  • Acquisitions: Acquisition of another company can be achieved without necessarily needing external finances as long as rights issues are involved, thus facilitating the company’s growth through strategic expansion.
  • Debt Reduction: The same money paid back as debt could simplify the growth of CAC, to start with crediting the company and then paying back those interests.
  • Maintaining Shareholder Control: By this means companies actually retain possession rights as their existing shareholders have been treated that way. Existing shareholders are given the preference and privilege of buying new shares, which would obstruct significant dilution of their own percentage of ownership and jeopardize controlling shares of the company.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: In contrast with other raising-money methods that include public offerings, rights issues can be less expensive or even more economical. It is usually saving of the expense with middlemen and underwriters because through crowdfunding way, a company can save more than out of the money raised.
  • Signalling Confidence: Considering that the issuance of the rights represents the company's commitment to its future performance, the company's existence. The Company recognizes its shareholders by giving them at a reduced rate shares that they hold. It shows the Company accords the shareholders the value they hold.

Advantages of Rights Issues

Rights issues offer several benefits for both companies and existing shareholders. Here's a detailed breakdown of the four key advantages:

Maintaining Shareholder Proportion

This is a critical advantage for existing shareholders, as it allows them to preserve their ownership percentage in the company. When a company issues new shares through a public offering, existing shareholders' ownership gets diluted as the total number of shares outstanding increases. However, with a rights issue, shareholders receive pre-emptive rights to purchase new shares proportionally to their existing holdings. This ensures that their voting power and ownership stake remain undiluted, even after the new shares are issued. This is particularly appealing to shareholders who value their voting rights and influence within the company.

Cost-Effective Capital Raising

Compared to other fundraising methods, rights issues are generally more cost-efficient for companies. The process typically involves lower fees associated with underwriting and marketing compared to public offerings. Underwriters are third-party financial institutions that help companies sell new shares to the public, and their services come at a cost. Rights issues bypass the need for underwriters, as existing shareholders are already familiar with the company and the investment opportunity. Additionally, since existing shareholders are offered the first opportunity to purchase new shares, the marketing and promotional costs associated with reaching out to a broader audience are significantly reduced.

Flexibility

Companies have greater control and flexibility over the terms of a rights issue compared to other capital-raising methods. This includes:

  • Pricing: Companies can offer the new shares at a discount to the current market price, making them more attractive to existing shareholders and potentially incentivizing participation.
  • Timing: They can choose the timing of the rights issue strategically, considering factors like market conditions and company performance.
  • Terms: They can establish specific terms and conditions associated with the rights, such as the exercise period (duration shareholders have to purchase the shares) and the minimum subscription threshold (percentage of shares they aim to raise through the offering).

This level of control allows companies to tailor the rights issue to their specific needs and market conditions, potentially increasing its success and minimizing potential risks.

Potential for Increased Shareholder Interest

Rights issues can serve as a positive signal to existing shareholders, demonstrating the company's commitment to their investment. By offering them the opportunity to acquire additional shares at a discount, companies acknowledge their value and potentially strengthen their relationship with these key stakeholders. This can lead to increased shareholder loyalty and confidence, which can benefit the company in the long run. Additionally, a successful rights issue can attract new investors, particularly those who view it as an indication of the company's growth potential and commitment to existing shareholders.

    Disadvantages of Rights Issues

    While offering several advantages, rights issues also come with potential drawbacks that companies need to carefully consider. Here's an in-depth exploration of the four primary disadvantages:

    Dilution Risk for Non-Participants 

    While rights issues aim to prevent dilution for participating shareholders, those who choose not to participate in the offering can experience a reduction in their ownership stake. This happens because the total number of shares outstanding increases with the issuance of new shares through the rights offering. Consequently, the ownership percentage of non-participating shareholders gets diluted, potentially impacting their voting power and proportional share of company profits. This can be particularly concerning for shareholders who hold significant stakes in the company.

    Potential Negative Market Perception

    Issuing a rights issue can sometimes be interpreted negatively by the market, especially if investors perceive it as a sign of financial difficulty or struggles to raise capital through other means. This negative perception can lead to a decrease in the company's stock price, further impacting existing shareholders and potentially hindering the success of the offering. Therefore, companies need to carefully manage their communication around the rights issue, emphasizing its purpose and potential benefits for the company's future prospects.

    Administrative Costs and Complexity

     Implementing a rights issue involves regulatory filings, administrative costs, and legal fees. Compared to simpler fundraising methods, they require significant upfront investment and time commitment. Companies need to prepare and distribute offer documents, liaise with regulatory bodies, and manage the subscription process. This increased administrative burden and associated costs can be a deterrent for companies with limited resources or tight timelines.

    Uncertainty of Success

    Rights issues are not guaranteed to be successful. There is a risk that not all shareholders will participate in the offering, potentially falling short of the company's desired capital raising target. This can be due to various factors, such as:

      • Shareholders who disagree with the terms of the offering, such as the discount price or the exercise period.
      • Shareholders who lack the financial resources to purchase additional shares.
      • A general lack of investor interest or enthusiasm for the company or its future prospects.

      If the rights issue fails to raise the desired amount, it can negatively impact the company's financial plans and potentially hinder its ability to achieve its strategic objectives.

      Additional Considerations

      Tax Implications

      The tax implications of rights issues can vary depending on the specific jurisdiction and the individual shareholder's situation. It's crucial for shareholders to be aware of the potential tax consequences of participating in the offering or selling their rights. These can include:

      • Taxation on Discounted Purchase: If shares are offered at a discount to the market price, the difference between the purchase price and the market value may be considered taxable income for the shareholder upon exercising their rights.
      • Capital Gains Tax: When shareholders sell their newly acquired shares through the rights issue, they might incur capital gains tax on the profits generated.
      • Tax on Sale of Rights: Shareholders who choose not to exercise their rights and instead sell them on the market may be subject to capital gains tax on the sale proceeds.

      It's highly recommended for shareholders to consult with a qualified tax advisor to understand the specific tax implications applicable to their individual circumstances and make informed decisions regarding their participation in the rights issue.

      Alternatives to Rights Issues

      While rights issues can be a valuable capital-raising tool, companies should also consider alternative options based on their specific needs and market conditions. Here are two common alternatives:

      • Public Share Issuance (IPO or Secondary Offering): Companies can raise capital by issuing new shares to the public through an initial public offering (IPO) or a secondary offering. This provides broader access to a wider pool of investors but can be more expensive and involve greater regulatory scrutiny compared to rights issues.
      • Debt Financing: Companies can raise capital by borrowing from banks or other lenders in the form of loans or bonds. Debt financing can be a faster and more straightforward option compared to issuing new equity, but it also comes with the obligation to repay the principal amount plus interest.

      Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, requiring careful evaluation by companies to determine the most suitable approach for their specific situation. Factors such as the cost of capital, potential dilution, regulatory requirements, and investor appetite should all be considered when making a well-informed decision regarding the appropriate capital-raising strategy.

      Conclusion

      However, capital issue requires company to give up the ownership share which could have been a concern while negotiating with the investors. Nevertheless, rights issue is cost-effective and preserve the shareholder control. Nevertheless, the shares of participators are diluted as a result and the system takes on rather great administrative functionality.

      In the end, the appropriateness of an IPO depends on each business setting. Substantial analysis of domestic needs, market oscillations, shareholders versatility, and alternative options must be carried before the management embark on a rights issue plan that can enable them to achieve the targeted capital raising objective. Consequently, the considering of every single element and possible results is the right way for company to make a clear decision and make sure that the needed investments are achieved for further business development and progress.

      Related Blogs:

      Leave a comment

      Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

      100% GST Approval

      Dedicated Account Manager

      Managed Compliances

      Post GST Approval Support